The Milburn Review makes the stark statement: “Health is no longer a background factor in youth disengagement: it is central…”

This recognition is welcome, but how far does the report go in to addressing how this can be resolved? What does it mean for the Occupational Health community.

“Many employers want to support them, but smaller firms in particular lack the capacity to do so. A large company may have HR, occupational health and specialist support. A small business often has an owner and a telephone. At present, for example, most young people and most small employers have little or no access to occupational health or retention support of this kind.”

This leaves open the tantalising question about whether access to occupational health expertise needs to be more accessible for employers.

The review goes onto say that, “GPs are experts in healthcare but are not employment-support or occupational-health specialists, and they do not necessarily have the time, expertise or incentives to provide dedicated advice on helping people remain in work.”

Again, the question remains whether GPs should have a better understanding of the relationship between occupation and health. 

Not surprisingly, the report comments that “The most important lesson from other countries is straightforward: health and employment support work better when they are organised together.” This raises the question of how best to achieve that better integration using the mechanisms that we have built in this country.

The report continues, “The test should be simple: ‘What intervention gives this young person the best chance of staying healthy and participating?’ Not, ‘Which NHS service can we offer them?’” However, the option of occupational health support is not really investigated.

The report concludes with a range of recommendations, suggesting that “preventative interventions should be able to substitute for avoidable medical intervention, rather than becoming an additional layer of activity.” Clearly, this signals that the crucial question is where resources would be best allocated to make the most impact on health.

The conclusions drawn favour the use of non-clinical help into work, but still don’t resolve the critical question. How do we best keep young people both working and healthy. Mayfield suggested last year that a conversation with a manager can make more impact on keeping someone in work than a chat with the GP. This is as much a truth about power relationships, as it is about practical support. However, aside from the assumption that working is always going to be better for health than not working, this still does not address the question of how we ensure that there are healthy jobs for all, both in terms of enabling the management of non-work related health conditions, but also ensuring work and the need to work does not cause ill-health.

There is much to be admired in the ardour, boldness and insight of the review, but it still misses the invaluable contribution that Government keeps on missing that is provided by the people who really do understand work and health – as embodied in our membership.

As Chair, I will be doing my utmost to point out the missed part of the jigsaw, as I am sure member bodies will.

 

 

Kevin Bampton

Chair

Council for Work and Health